Reflection on Library as Classroom

NMC Horizon Report: 2014 Higher Education Edition

Bringing emotional intelligence into the library is deceptively simplistic. One example of this is at the San Francisco Public Library (and likely other public libraries). If anyone (especially a child) does not have their library card, they can go ask a librarian to check out their books without a card by writing down their first and last name and birthdate for the librarian to look up their account. While this may seem like a small or insignificant offering, it is an incredible value add when teaching children, all of whom experienced severe social and communal disconnection during the pandemic and in the years following, how to speak to adults and self-advocate. 

I was made aware of this for the first time by my son who is now 11 years old a couple of years ago. For context, not only is he neurodiverse, he is so unbearably shy that at family gatherings hosted in our own home, he will refuse to come down from his bedroom because there are too many people he may not know in the house. One day my son informed me that even though he did not bring his library card with him (standard!) he did not need to check out books under my card; instead he would go to the librarian and ask them to look up his account. I’m not sure whether you can appreciate the shock of hearing that this child is going up to (trustworthy adult) strangers and asking for what he needs. This was an unexpected experience of the power of libraries as places where children even with different needs can feel accepted and supported by library workers who they have never met before and may never see again. 

We have continued to use the library as a space to build confidence and self-advocacy. In many branches they host a scavenger hunt in the children’s section where there are small cut out pictures hidden around, and children can take a sheet with all of the pictures and cross them off as they find them. Once they find all of the images, they can go to the librarian desk and select a small prize. However, even with my help, my 7 year old daughter often cannot find all of the pictures. When this happens, I let her know that she is welcome to go ask the librarian for a hint. At first when she was a bit younger and newer to this, she refused to do this and demanded that I accompany her to request help, which I did. One day I said, no you can go on your own. If you feel too shy you can ask your brother to go with you. Now, my daughter is competitive and I do not think she liked the insinuation that her brother could do something that she could not. Nevertheless, she asked him to go with her and they got the information she needed. Eventually, she built up the courage to go ask the librarian for help and even go turn in her finished sheet to collect a prize by herself. 

I teach my kids that asking for help is an important life skill and a sign of maturity. I feel so fortunate that the library provides a space for these lessons to be tested and reinforced in real time. 

Reflection on New Horizons: AI & Trust

image

“While AI already exists in much of the technology we engage with in our everyday lives, the potential spread of unregulated generative AI raises questions about how it is being used in education settings, along with the integrity of the data being used by the technology.” IFLA TREND 3: Trust is Being Renegotiated. 

Amira Learning is an AI-powered learning agent that purports to support reading growth through one-on-one engagements with a student who reads to the AI, which in turn provides real-time support and identifies reading errors, among other functionality (Tucker, 2026). Parents and educators across the country are challenging use of Amira based on concerns over privacy, consent, psychological/educational harm to students, among other ethical principles and values (Tucker, 2026).

Amira is being used by the San Francisco Unified School District (and many districts across the country) to help public school students learn how to read. Unfortunately, this is a hallmark example of trust being renegotiated very poorly. (Note: Both of my kids are enrolled in SFUSD and have used Amira.)

The way Amira works is a student reads to AI through a microphone, and an onscreen cartoon provides coaching and correction to the student in real time over the student’s headset. These coaching prompts are not spontaneous but based on programmed algorithms. It is meant to be used approximately 30 minutes total in a given school week (e.g., in 2-3 sessions per week). Amira records student sessions and these recordings are accessible by the student’s teacher at a later date, but are purportedly not shared on broader platforms and are not used to teach Amira’s AI.  

Amira was instituted by SFUSD at the start of the 2025 school year in all classrooms K-5 without any notification to or consent by parents, which eroded trust. The program listens to children as they read and provides corrections. SFUSD parents did not have notification of use of the program and were not given a chance to opt out of it, until it had already been in place for one full school year. This breach of trust has sparked outrage among San Francisco parents who have not had a chance to learn about or opt out of the program for an entire school year. The Amira program continues to be used, but an informational document has recently been provided to parents, which includes a notification that parents can contact their student’s teacher to opt out of participation with Amira. It is not clear what supplementary instruction might be available to students who opt out, meaning they may be disadvantaged by not getting any one-on-one instruction from an educator in place of that Amira time.

The list of AI’s potential harms grows increasingly larger as technology becomes integrated into social institutions. The ethical principle of non-maleficence includes not only deliberate harm but also actions that increase the risk of psychological or social harm. AI can create these risks through the collection, processing, storage, and sharing of personal information, all of which are part of Amira’s platform (Mooradian, 2018). It can also create risk through algorithms that have not been properly vetted to achieve their desired outcome or tested for unforeseen impacts, as is the case with Amira. 

The principle of fairness is indicated where Amira is being implemented in educational spaces where racial minorities are overrepresented. This means that not only will they be disproportionately impacted but their districts are earmarking important funds for this under-researched technology that may be better invested in other well-established resources such as teacher training or additional para educators. 

An opportunity for libraries in this instance is improving AI literacy. Where trust has been breached and public institutions are not properly vetting new technologies being used on vulnerable populations, one of the most important steps that can be taken is learning more about the issue and how to break it down into parts. In this instance, a list of questions are helpful to inform discussion on and reckoning with the use of Amira in classrooms. 

  • Were parents clearly notified before implementation, and if so, were they informed in understandable language so that they could properly consent or opt out?
  • How is student biometric data collected, how is it protected, and how long is it retained?
  • Can parents request deletion of student data?
  • How are we ensuring student data is not being used to train AI?
  • Were students who participated in initial studies appropriately compensated and did their families provide informed consent to enrich Amira with their personal data?
  • How is the impact being monitored to ensure that students are not being psychologically, emotionally harmed by Amira’s technology?
  • Is this program being used disproportionately in under-served and under-resourced minoritized populations such that they will encounter the brunt of any negative impacts?  
  • Why are we looking to AI instead of addressing root causes of literacy which are heavily socioeconomic? Is this the appropriate tool to answer this question?
  • Why are we not paying teachers more and hiring more teachers and professional educators? 
  • Is the primary focus of this tool to obscure the root causes of socioeconomic disenfranchisement in marginalized communities that results in lower literacy?

It is concerning that such technology could be so broadly implemented before meaningful engagement in an ethical impact assessment. It is unfortunate that decisionmakers could be so seduced by technology before engaging in and publicizing these risks and assessments of risks before moving forward with such substantial investments with potential impacts on this vulnerable population who have minimal ability to self-advocate. However, where there is conflict and the potential for harm, there is also the potential to learn and grow in community. This circumstance highlights the value of building AI literacy within our community and libraries certainly have a role to play in cultivating this new ethical landscape.

 

References

Amira Learning. (2026, May). Delivering equity: Evidence that Amira’s reading assessment tests every learner fairly and accurately [White paper]. https://explore.amiralearning.com/hubfs/Amira-Equity-White-Paper.pdf 

Dezuanni, M., & Osman, K. (2024). IFLA Trend Report 2024: Facing the future of information with confidence. International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions. https://www.ifla.org/trend-report/

Mooradian, N. (2018). Ethics for records and information management. ALA Neal-Schuman. 

Tucker, J. (2026, September 16). This AI tool helps kids learn to read. Why are S.F. parents rallying against it? San Francisco Chronicle. https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/ai-reading-school-san-francisco-22431436.php

[WILD CARD Reflection] Global Library Trends & Romance Readers

[image sources: @bookitwithehss; @britandherbooks; @docmollyreads;  @reparations.club; @thestackspod]

 

Two trends outlined in the IFLA Trend Report, which is designed to help support the future of libraries so that they can remain resilient and sustainable, highlight the power and opportunity for global impact for romance novel readers as an information community.

One trend is related to the social isolation and loneliness and the significance of this problem worldwide across age groups, with detrimental health impacts as comparable to smoking and obesity. Globally, people are seeking or in dire need of community connections on a variety of levels, whether local, online or somewhere in between.

Another trend closely related to the romance reader information community is improvement of equity in knowledge systems. Knowledge is and will continue to expand beyond existing privileged, Western, patriarchal voices and norms. People are seeking diverse stories as a basis for connection and learning, and this expansion will heal and build communities.

Romance & Addressing the Loneliness Epidemic

Romance readers are a lively bunch and enjoy the connections that reading this genre can yield, whether it’s via social media or connecting with friends in real live. While there has traditionally been a hefty amount of stigma associated with reading romance novels due to their varying degrees of salacious sexual content, the increasing activity of romance readers online communities has bolstered the credibility and validity of this genre. “One of the joys of smut is the sense of community it builds. There’s something special about realizing a friend is ‘in on it’” (Huizenga, 2024).

TikTok (aka “BookTok”), Instagram (aka “Bookstagram”), and forums like Reddit’s “r/RomanceBooks” have contributed to destigmatization the genre by giving romance readers a platform to “share their love for steamy reads with pride, even humorously celebrating them in ways that once might have been considered taboo” (Huizenga, 2024).Some libraries dedicate substantial efforts to romance programming, thereby investing in community building both in person and online. The Arlington Public Library’s author talk series, Arlington Reads, hosted five romance authors in 2025. The Berkeley Public Library North branch sponsors the Modern Romance Book Club and hosted five in-person events in 2025. There are many opportunities and formats for libraries to support the romance reader information community and thus providing frameworks to address the future of the loneliness epidemic.

Romance & Futuristic Ways of Knowing

Romance novels, writers and the overall publishing industry have historically not embraced diversity in many categories including, race, neurodivergence, disability and fat representation. However, there are writers who are presently contributing to enriching the genre with their characters and storylines (Nankervis, 2022). The publishing industry’s current repertoire is far too white, cis, hetero, neurotypical, able bodied and thin; industry has an obligation to use money and influence to promote diverse writers and stories, because these stories sell and they deserve to be told and read by all (Nankervis, 2022).

Diversity and representation in romance novels are important not only to readers who represent certain marginalized and minoritized communities, but also to all readers, because readers can and do identify with characters who are different from them (Nankervis, 2022). Romance readers do not need to explicitly share an identity with the characters in the books they read in order to enjoy them (e.g., vampires, werewolves, etc.) (Nankervis, 2022).

Often this genre is denigrated based on its association with women readers and its perception as a “frivolous, escapist pursuit” (Greenhaus, 2023). However, as discussed above regarding the immense health benefits of reading and talking about romance novels in community, not to mention promoting literacy, reading this genre allows for self-replenishing as well as tending to individual emotional needs (Dewan, 2010; Greenhaus, 2023). That the benefits of romance novel reading are so clear and well known in certain marginalized circles, and yet not discussed or central in the discourse of this genre, is because these impacts are enjoyed by (mainly) women.

Globally, from the United States to New South Wales, librarians’ treatment of romance on the shelves can connote negativity, held broadly in society—marking romance novels with a heart in fiction sections, harkening to romance readers and yet informing other fiction readers to look away, or placing them in carousels away from “normal” fiction (Veros, 2023). To these librarians, romance fiction is a dalliance, not meaningful, intellectual or otherwise nourishing (Veros, 2023).

Harlequins serve as an important fantasy vehicle that offers an escape route for women trapped in dysfunctional families, [bell hooks] says. Not because someday your prince will come, but because “you will triumph over it and it will all come right in the end.” (Parker, 1999)

Romance readers reflect an opening up of possibilities and eschewing the limits of toxic patriarchy. “Without an ethic of love shaping the direction of our political vision and our radical aspirations, we are often seduced, in one way or the other, into continued allegiance to systems of domination–imperialism, sexism, racism, classism” (hooks, 2006, p. 243).

Even among a range of romance readers who have, at best, never heard of bell hooks or, otherwise, would say they disagree fundamentally with her values, would likely agree that romance novels are like old medicine and wisdom passed down through generations, with readers healing themselves and allowing them the respite to continue to show up with and for their communities in the face of capitalist, patriarchal oppression—even if they would not fashion their lived experiences in such politicized terms.

As librarians are uniquely situated in institutions nearly exclusively focused on lifelong learning and supporting communities, the collective impact of embracing and supporting the romance reader information community cannot be understated (Dewan, 2016). Where librarians ascribe to the overt or subconscious framing of romance as a lesser form of fiction, they do a disservice to their readers and the community (Veros, 2023).

Investigation into and support for what the romance reader information community can offer is imperative at a time when society is challenging traditional, heteronormative, patriarchal approaches to leisure, value and who gets to write history and define what matters. Let’s listen to and study the collective wisdom of romance readers.   

References:

Dewan, P. (2010). Why your academic library needs a popular reading collection now more than ever. College & Undergraduate Libraries, 17(1), 44–64. https://doi.org/10.1080/10691310903584775

Dewan, P. (2016). Economic well-being and social justice through pleasure reading. New Library World, 117(9/10), 557–567. https://doi-org.libaccess.sjlibrary.org/10.1108/NLW-03-2016-0019

Dezuanni, M., Osman, K. Burton, A. & Heck, E. (2024). IFLA Trend Report: Facing the future of information with confidence: Phase 2. Brisbane: Digital Media Research Centre. https://www.ifla.org/trend-report/

Greenhaus, R. (2023). Sex in the stacks: Examining the treatment of explicit materials in American libraries. Libri: International Journal of Libraries & Information Services, 73(1), 77–84. https://doi.org/10.1515/libri-2021-0133

hooks, b. (2006). Outlaw Culture: Resisting Representations. Routledge.

Huizenga, H. (2024, December 3). SMUT: The juicy secret we’re all finally talking about. Medium. https://baos.pub/smut-the-juicy-secret-were-all-finally-talking-about-7e9401415ff4

Nankervis, M. (2022). Diversity in romance novels: Race, sexuality, neurodivergence, disability, and fat representation. Publishing Research Quarterly, 38(2), 349–363. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12109-022-09881-6

Parker, L. O. (1999, February 20). Fantasy aisle: Harlequin romance novels steam through 50 years of changing mores. The Washington Post.

Veros, V. (2023, May 30). Nobody puts romance fiction in the corner: Public librarians in New South Wales and their dalliance with romance fiction. Journal of Popular Romance Studies. https://www.jprstudies.org/2023/05/nobody-puts-romance-fiction-in-the-corner-public-librarians-in-new-south-wales-and-their-dalliance-with-romance-fiction/